Forester's Field KitField Kit

Courses · Study guide

Hardwood defect ID

What to look for in each defect. When you're ready, test yourself.

Grading defects: severity and AGS / UGS

From the Forest Health course and the Ontario Tree Marking Guide (p. 66). Many trees have more than one defect.

ClassMeaning
AGS — Acceptable Growing StockForm and appearance suggest it can reasonably be expected to maintain and/or improve its quality, and contribute vigorous, high-quality stems to future crops (likely to keep growing for another ~20 years).
UGS — Unacceptable Growing StockHigh risk: expected to decline during the next cutting cycle (likely to die in the next 20–25 years), so it can be harvested. May also be of poor form or low quality that can't be expected to improve.
ModerateEither way

Moderate defects reduce quality potential and the tree will degrade slowly. They can go either way: AGS or UGS.

MinorAlways AGS

Minor defects are always AGS: the tree will maintain its quality over the cutting cycle.

Stem form

Crook

Crook

Minor · AGS
  • An abrupt bend or dog-leg in the stem, usually where the leader was lost and a branch took over.
  • The kink is short and sharp; a sweep is a long, gradual curve.

Don't confuse with: Sweep, Lean greater than 10°

Sweep

Sweep

Minor · AGS
  • A long, gradual curve along the stem.
  • The bend is spread over the length of the log; a crook is a sharp kink.

Don't confuse with: Crook, Lean greater than 10°

Burl

Burl

Minor · AGS
  • A rounded, bark-covered swelling on the stem.
  • Inside, the grain is swirled and twisted.

Don't confuse with: Clinker fungus, Butt flare

Butt flare (Barreling)

Butt flare

Barreling
Major · UGS
  • The base of the stem bulges or swells out like a barrel.
  • Can mean butt rot inside the lower log.

Rating: Major · UGS Only counts as barreling when the bloat is in the first 2 m of the stem.

Don't confuse with: Burl, Sweep

Lean greater than 10°

Lean greater than 10°

Moderate · AGS or UGS
  • The whole stem tilts more than 10° away from vertical.
  • The stem can be straight; it is the angle from the base that counts.

Don't confuse with: Sweep, Crook

Epicormic branching

Epicormic branching

Minor · AGS
  • Small sprouts and twigs growing straight out of the main stem.
  • Often appears after the tree is stressed or suddenly opened up.

Don't confuse with: Burl, Punk knot fungus

Scars, seams & cavities

Dark face scar

Dark face scar

  • An open wound where the exposed wood has gone dark and soft.
  • Dark wood is a sign that decay has already set in behind the scar.

Rating: Smaller than 900 cm²: Moderate · AGS or UGS · Larger than 900 cm²: Major · UGS Small dark face scars (< 900 cm²) are moderate. 900 cm² is 30 × 30 cm, a little bigger than a sheet of paper. Large dark face scars (> 900 cm²) are major. 900 cm² is 30 × 30 cm, a little bigger than a sheet of paper.

Don't confuse with: White face scar, Cavity on main stem

Sun scald

Sun scald

Moderate · AGS or UGS
  • Long, vertical strips of dead bark that crack and peel away.
  • On the sunny south or southwest side, often after the stand was opened up.

Rating: Moderate · AGS or UGS Found on young trees; the scar faces the sun.

Don't confuse with: Frost crack, White face scar

White face scar

White face scar

Minor · AGS
  • Bark (callus) is growing over and covering the wound.
  • Any exposed wood is still pale and firm: decay has not taken hold yet.

Don't confuse with: Dark face scar, Sun scald

Fluxing seam

Fluxing seam

  • A seam or crack that weeps sap, leaving a dark, wet-looking stain down the bark.
  • The fluxing (bleeding) is what sets it apart from a plain frost crack.

Rating: Moderate · AGS or UGS · Actively oozing: Moderate · UGS A fluxing seam that is oozing is UGS.

Don't confuse with: Frost crack, Spiral seam, Black bark

Frost crack (Seam)

Frost crack

Seam
Moderate · AGS or UGS
  • A straight, vertical crack running up the stem.
  • Often has ridges of callus along its edges where it has tried to heal.

Don't confuse with: Spiral seam, Fluxing seam, Sun scald

Spiral seam

Spiral seam

Moderate · AGS or UGS
  • A seam or crack that twists around the stem.
  • It follows a spiral grain instead of running straight up.

Don't confuse with: Frost crack, Fluxing seam

Cavity on main stem

Cavity on main stem

Major · UGS
  • An open hole leading into the stem.
  • Means decay inside, but may also be used as a wildlife den or nest.

Rating: Major · UGS UGS, but keep the tree when you can: cavities are good for wildlife.

Don't confuse with: Dark face scar, Punk knot fungus

Conks & decay fungi

True tinder fungus

True tinder fungus

Fomes fomentarius
Major · UGS
  • Hard, hoof-shaped conks that are grey with lighter and darker bands.
  • Most often on birch and beech; several conks often line up on the stem.
  • A sign of white rot in the stem.

Rating: Major · UGS Usually found on dead birch.

Don't confuse with: False tinder fungus, Artist’s conk

Spine tooth fungus

Spine tooth fungus

Climacodon septentrionalis
Major · UGS
  • Large, overlapping clusters of cream to white shelves.
  • Teeth or spines, not pores, on the underside.
  • Usually on sugar maple; a sign of heart rot.

Don't confuse with: Mossy top fungus, Yellow cap fungus

Clinker fungus (Chaga)

Clinker fungus

Chaga · Inonotus obliquus
Major · UGS
  • A black, deeply cracked mass that looks like burnt charcoal.
  • Grows out of the stem, mostly on birch; the inside is rusty orange-brown.
  • A sign of extensive heart rot.

Rating: Major · UGS Mainly found on yellow and white birch.

Don't confuse with: Coal fungus, Black knot on cherry, Burl

Shoestring root rot (Armillaria)

Shoestring root rot

Armillaria · Armillaria spp.
Major · UGS
  • Black, shoestring-like strands (rhizomorphs) under the bark.
  • White fans of fungus between the bark and the wood.
  • Clusters of honey-coloured mushrooms at the base of the tree in the fall.

Rating: Major · UGS Think shoes: it is on the roots, at the base of the tree.

Don't confuse with: Yellow cap fungus, Coal fungus

Punk knot fungus

Punk knot fungus

Major · UGS
  • A swollen knot or branch stub with soft, punky, rotten wood in the middle.
  • Shows that decay has entered the stem through the old branch.

Don't confuse with: False tinder fungus, Burl

Coal fungus

Coal fungus

Daldinia concentrica
Major · UGS
  • Black, brittle, crusty patches that look like lumps of coal.
  • Found at the base of the tree; a sign of butt rot.

Don't confuse with: Clinker fungus, Black bark

Yellow cap fungus

Yellow cap fungus

Pholiota spp.
Major · UGS
  • Clusters of yellow to golden mushrooms with caps and stalks.
  • Often grow out of wounds or seams on the stem; a sign of decay.

Rating: Major · UGS Grows on the stem from a seam.

Don't confuse with: Shoestring root rot, Spine tooth fungus

False tinder fungus

False tinder fungus

Phellinus igniarius
Major · UGS
  • Hoof-shaped conk with a black, deeply cracked top.
  • Rusty-brown to light edge and a brown pore surface underneath.
  • A sign of heavy heart rot.

Rating: Major · UGS Almost always (99%) on poplar.

Don't confuse with: True tinder fungus, Artist’s conk, Punk knot fungus

Mossy top fungus

Mossy top fungus

Oxyporus populinus
Moderate · UGS
  • Small, white, overlapping shelves, often covered in moss on top.
  • Usually on maple; a sign of heart rot.

Rating: Moderate · UGS Mossy top is a moderate defect, but always UGS.

Don't confuse with: Spine tooth fungus, Artist’s conk

Artist’s conk

Artist’s conk

Ganoderma applanatum
Major · UGS
  • Flat, shelf-like conk with a brown top.
  • White pore surface underneath that turns brown when scratched.
  • Usually low on the stem; a sign of butt rot.

Don't confuse with: True tinder fungus, False tinder fungus, Mossy top fungus

Cankers, diseases & insects

Butternut canker

Butternut canker

Major · UGS
  • Sunken, elongated cankers on butternut, often with black, sooty, inky stains.
  • Leads to dying branches and a thinning crown.
  • Butternut is an endangered species in Ontario.

Don't confuse with: Black bark, Nectria canker, Eutypella canker

Black bark

Black bark

Major · UGS
  • Patches or streaks of bark that have turned black, unlike the rest of the stem.
  • Look for where the dark bark starts and stops along the trunk.

Don't confuse with: Butternut canker, Fluxing seam, Coal fungus

Sugar maple borer

Sugar maple borer

Moderate · AGS or UGS
  • A curved, S-shaped or diagonal scar on sugar maple, with a callus ridge around it.
  • Left by the larva tunnelling under the bark.

Don't confuse with: Dark face scar, Eutypella canker

Nectria canker (Target canker)

Nectria canker

Target canker
Major · UGS
  • Rings of callus around a sunken centre, like a target.
  • The bark falls away from the centre, showing the ridges.

Don't confuse with: Eutypella canker, Butternut canker

Eutypella canker (Cobra canker)

Eutypella canker

Cobra canker
Major · UGS
  • A large canker on maple with bark still stuck to the centre.
  • Thick, swollen callus around the edge gives a cobra-head shape.

Don't confuse with: Nectria canker, Sugar maple borer

Beech bark disease

Beech bark disease

Major · UGS
  • White, woolly specks of scale insects on smooth beech bark.
  • Once the fungus is in: small orange-red fruiting bodies in lemon-shaped patterns, then cankers and cracked bark.

Rating: Major · UGS Only UGS once the fruiting bodies are there. Scale insects alone are not UGS.

Don't confuse with: Nectria canker, Black bark

Black knot on cherry

Black knot on cherry

  • Hard, black, lumpy swellings on the twigs and branches of cherry.
  • Looks like burnt sausages wrapped around the branch.

Rating: Moderate · AGS or UGS · More than 50% of the crown affected: Moderate · UGS Mainly found on cherry species. Black knot on more than 50% of the crown is UGS.

Don't confuse with: Clinker fungus, Coal fungus